Pork Tenderloin Pinwheels with Mustard Sauce
Pork tenderloin pinwheels are thin strips of tenderloin rolled up with bacon, pinned with toothpicks, crusted with pecans, and grilled direct over hot coals until the bacon chars and the pork hits 145°F. Finish them with a tangy Carolina mustard sauce and a pinch of fleur de sel. It is a show-stopping appetizer that feeds a group of 6, and it comes from the pages of a legendary competition BBQ book.
Where This Recipe Comes From
Last weekend we fired up the Weber Performer grill and cracked open a new cookbook: “Big Bob Gibson’s BBQ Book: Recipes and Secrets from a Legendary BBQ Joint“, written by Chris Lilly, the VP of Big Bob Gibson’s, head of their award-winning competition team, and a big honcho in the BBQ world.
Our first foray was into the Pecan Crusted Pork Tenderloin Pinwheels. For the full ingredient amounts, grab the book; here is how we cooked them and what we learned.
How to Build the Pinwheels
The pinwheels are infused with bacon: thin strips of pork tenderloin are cut lengthwise, then wrapped with bacon. Two toothpicks help you keep each one together. Why two? One lets the pinwheel spin and unroll when you flip it; two lock it in place.
Tenderloin is lean, so the bacon does double duty here. It bastes the pork as it renders and gives you crisp, salty edges against the pecan crust.
Grilling Direct Over the Coals
We cooked these direct over the coals, and you can see some of the pinwheels picked up a nice little char. Thin pork cooks fast, so stay at the grill and turn them as the bacon crisps.
Pull them at 145°F in the center, the USDA safe temperature for whole cuts of pork, and let them rest 3 minutes. An instant-read thermometer is the only way to know; tenderloin goes from juicy to dry in a couple of minutes.
If the bacon is not crisp by the time the pork hits 145°F, slide the pinwheels to the hottest part of the grate for a quick sear on each side. Chasing crispy bacon with more total cook time is how tenderloin dries out.
Hawk’s Tip
The Carolina Mustard Sauce
Also helping the flavor is the Carolina mustard sauce. Something of a religious conversation, Carolina mustard sauce is either loved or hated. The mustard was great: just a little Tabasco kept the flavors moving without killing your mouth. A little fleur de sel and pepper to finish it off went nicely, our own touch.
We paired it with Rogue Voodoo Doughnut Bacon Maple Ale. The beer was a little overpowering, however, so pick something lighter if you are pouring along.
Serving
Serve the pinwheels hot off the grill with the mustard sauce on the side for dipping. It is a good portioned appetizer for a group of 6. For a full pork spread, pair them with our peach pork tenderloin, ancho chili pork chops with bourbon caramelized apples, or pork belly burnt ends.
Pork Tenderloin Pinwheels FAQ
What temperature should pork tenderloin pinwheels be cooked to?
145°F in the center, followed by a 3 minute rest. That is the USDA safe temperature for whole cuts of pork, and it keeps lean tenderloin juicy.
What is Carolina mustard sauce?
It is a tangy, yellow, mustard-based BBQ sauce from South Carolina, usually sharpened with vinegar and a little sweetness. Ours got a few dashes of Tabasco for heat.
Should I grill pinwheels direct or indirect?
We grilled them direct over the coals. They are thin, so direct heat crisps the bacon and chars the edges before the pork overcooks.
Keep Going
- The Peach Pork Tenderloin Experiment
- Ancho Chili Pork Chops with Bourbon Caramelized Apples
- Easy Pork Belly Burnt Ends
- Smoked Bacon-Wrapped Jalapeno Poppers (Lil Fatties)
Get the next recipe first.
New cooks, gear picks, and playlists in your inbox. No fluff, just fire.
I adore pork tenderloin – my favourite cut of pork, even above bacon :D.
Yum! Great party appetizer idea!
Thanks for the comments! We’re a big fan here too.