Sausage and Cheddar Stuffed Jalapeno Poppers
These sausage stuffed jalapeno poppers are the tray that empties first at every tailgate. Halved jalapenos get packed with browned Italian sausage, sharp cheddar and cream cheese, wrapped in thick cut bacon, dusted with smoked paprika and grilled at 425F until the bacon crisps and the filling bubbles. About 40 minutes on the grill, and they eat like a mini meal instead of a snack.
I posted a video of these poppers to friends on the Grilling Community on Reddit and got a great response, with multiple requests to post the recipe. We’re used to doing jalapeno poppers with just cheese, but the sausage and cheddar approach gets to mini-meal level of quality and flavor. Definitely one to do for your next BBQ or party.
Prepping and Seeding the Jalapenos
Buy the biggest, straightest jalapenos in the bin. Fat, flat peppers sit level on the grate, hold more filling and don’t tip over and dump cheese into the fire.
Put on food prep gloves before you cut anything. Halve each pepper lengthwise, stem and all, then run a spoon down the middle to scoop out the seeds and the white ribs. Most of the heat lives in those ribs, so scraping them clean tames the burn and opens up room for more filling. Leave a few ribs in if your crowd likes it hot.
Building the Sausage and Cheddar Filling
Brown a pound of ground Italian sausage in a skillet over medium-high heat, mild or hot to your taste. Break it into chunks big enough to sit in the pepper, not fine crumbles. Chunky filling stays put; fine crumbles turn to paste and ooze out on the grill.
Drain the sausage well, drop the heat to low and stir in cubed cream cheese and shredded cheddar until everything softens and binds. Draining matters: leftover grease pools in the pepper and drips onto the coals, which means flare-ups and a greasy popper. The cream cheese is the glue, the cheddar brings the sharp bite.
Wrapping the Poppers in Bacon
Mound the filling slightly above the rim of each pepper boat. Cut the bacon in half crosswise and wrap one half around each popper, tucking the ends underneath so the weight of the pepper holds them in place. We use Hempler’s thick cut bacon here because thick slices survive 40 minutes of high heat without burning through. Thin bacon works, but watch it closer.
Finish with a dusting of smoked paprika or your favorite BBQ rub. The paprika gives the bacon a deep red color as it cooks, and on a party platter color sells the first bite.
Grilling Temps and Timing
Preheat the grill to 425F and set the poppers on the upper rack, away from direct flame. Give them at least 20 minutes before you open the lid. Every peek dumps heat and slows the bacon. Plan on about 40 minutes total. They’re done when the filling reads 160F in the middle on an instant read thermometer and the bacon is browned and crisp to your liking.
A jalapeno pepper rack keeps the boats upright and makes it easy to move a full batch on and off the grill in one shot. Not required, but handy if you make these often.
Rather run them on the smoker? Go hotter than your usual low and slow. At typical pulled pork temps the bacon renders but stays chewy. Either finish them over higher heat to crisp the bacon or run the smoker hot from the start, and judge doneness by the 160F filling and bacon color, not the clock.
Let them rest a full 10 minutes off the grill. The cheese is molten when they come off and will slide right out of the pepper if you bite too soon. Resting sets the filling and saves a few burned tongues.
Hawk’s Tip
Make Ahead and Serving
You can seed, fill and wrap the poppers the day before. Cover the tray and refrigerate, then grill straight from the fridge, checking the 160F filling temp since cold poppers run a little longer. That frees up your morning for the main cook.
For game day, build the spread around them. Set the poppers out next to our hot honey wings, a tray of party ribs and a pile of smoked pigs in a blanket, put backyard smashburgers on for the main, and let a pan of smoked pit beans handle the side. Feeding a bigger crowd? Brisket burnt ends go as fast as the poppers do.
Short on time? Pull a few more ideas from our last minute Big Game grilling ideas. Want the bacon wrapped, cheese only version? Our Lil Fatties bacon wrapped poppers from PNW Eggfest are the classic take.
Sausage and Cheddar Stuffed Jalapeno Poppers
4
servings30
minutes40
minutesIngredients
1 lb. large green jalapenos, halved lengthwise
1 pkg. Hempler’s Thick Cut Bacon (or your favorite)
1 lb. Ground Italian sausage (Mild or Hot to your taste)
3/4 c. Shredded cheddar cheese
4 oz. Philadelphia Cream Cheese
3 Tbsp. Smoked Paprika or your favorite BBQ rub.
Directions
- Pre-heat Grill to 425 deg F.
- Wearing food preparation gloves, cut the Jalapenos lengthwise and use a spoon to scoop out the seeds and ribbing
- In a medium skillet, brown the sausage over med-high heat and break up the sausage into chunks large enough to fit into the jalapeno. These should be chunky or they will ooze out during grilling.
- Drain sausage, turn heat to low and add cubed cream cheese and cheddar cheese. Allow to soften and stir to mix.
- Fill each Jalapeno boat with the mixture, slightly above top of each boat.
- Cut bacon in half cross-wise and wrap each boat.
- Sprinkle smoked paprika or your favorite rub to taste. The paprika gives the bacon a great color as it cooks.
- Place Jalapeno boats on the upper rack and allow to cook at least 20 minutes before you look. Temp to 160 degrees F in the middle and bacon is done to your liking.
- Remove from grill and allow to rest 10 minutes. Enjoy!
Recipe Video
Get the next recipe first.
New cooks, gear picks, and playlists in your inbox. No fluff, just fire.
Stuffed Jalapeno Poppers FAQ
How long do you grill stuffed jalapeno poppers?
About 40 minutes at 425F on the upper rack. Don’t open the lid for the first 20 minutes, then pull them when the filling hits 160F and the bacon is crisp.
Do you cook the sausage before stuffing jalapenos?
Yes. Brown and drain the sausage first. The peppers aren’t on the grill long enough to cook raw sausage through evenly, and precooking gets rid of the grease that would otherwise pool in the boat and cause flare-ups.
How do you make stuffed jalapenos less spicy?
Scrape out every seed and all of the white ribs, and use mild Italian sausage. The cream cheese and cheddar also cool things down. For more heat, leave some ribs in and go with hot sausage.
Can you make sausage stuffed jalapenos ahead of time?
Yes. Fill and wrap them up to a day ahead, cover and refrigerate, then grill when your guests arrive. Go by the 160F filling temp, since cold poppers take a little longer.
Can I make these in the oven?
You can bake them at the same 425F on a rack set over a sheet pan, using the same 160F filling target. You’ll lose the touch of smoke and grill char, but the bacon still crisps.
Keep Going
- Smoked Pigs in a Blanket with Everything Bagel Seasoning
- Crispy Smoked Spicy Wings with Hot Honey Glaze
- Backyard Smashburgers with Crispy Lacy Edges
- Smoked Pit Beans
- The Ultimate Guide to Smoking Party Ribs
- Pork Belly Burnt Ends
- Lil Fatties: Bacon Wrapped Jalapeno Poppers
- Last Minute Big Game Grilling Ideas
2 Comments