Beecher’s Flagship Burger Cheese Sauce
Trade the boring cheese slice for this: a Beecher’s Flagship burger cheese sauce made with heavy cream, sharp cheddar, and a kick of cayenne and chipotle. It is rich, keto friendly, and thick enough to pour over a burger fresh off the grill or dunk fries into. Here is how we make it, plus the one trick that keeps it from going grainy.
Why Beecher’s Flagship
In Seattle, Beecher’s Handmade Cheese is an institution. Nestled in the heart of Pike Place Market, you can watch their signature cheeses being made, including their Flagship, which defies definition, while munching on their famous grilled cheese or mac and cheese. There’s a reason Oprah named their mac one of her “Favorite Things,” causing a nationwide run on it. We wanted to recreate that taste for a spring and summer favorite: burgers. After a fair amount of experimentation, here is the sauce.
How to Keep Cheese Sauce Smooth
Bring the cream just to a boil, then drop the heat to medium-low before any cheese goes in. Add the grated Flagship slowly while you whisk, then the cheddar. Heat is the enemy here: too hot and the cheese breaks, turning oily and grainy. If it needs body, whisk in a little almond flour, which thickens it and keeps it keto. A small heavy enameled cast iron saucepan and a good balloon whisk make it easy to hold that gentle heat.
Season at the end, not the start. Cayenne and chipotle bloom as the sauce sits, so add half, taste, then decide. You can always add heat; you cannot take it back out.
Hawk’s Tip
Ingredients and Directions
Ingredients
3/4 c. Heavy Cream
2 c. Beecher’s Flagship (small wedge)
1 c. Shredded Sharp Cheddar (your favorite type)
1 tsp. Cayenne Pepper (or to taste)
1 tsp. Chipotle Pepper
1/4 c. Almond Flour (as needed)
Directions
- In small saucepan, bring heavy cream just to boil under medium heat.
- Grate Beecher’s Flagship, thick grate is fine.
- While stirring with a whisk, slowly add Beecher’s into heavy cream under med-low heat.
- Add shredded cheddar cheese
- Continue to heat, to thicken, add a little Almond flour
- Add Cayenne and Chipotle pepper to taste

- Remove heat, a film may develop this is not a problem just reheat and stir.
- Pour over burgers fresh off the grill to the delight of everyone

How to Use Beecher’s Cheese Sauce
Burgers first. Spoon it over a patty right off the grill, or swap it for the American cheese on our Oklahoma onion burgers or our crispy-edged backyard smashburgers. It is thick enough to dip fries in, and it is great over grilled vegetables. If you love that Beecher’s flavor, take it all the way with our smoked Beecher’s mac and cheese.
Beecher’s Cheese Sauce FAQ
Is this cheese sauce keto friendly?
Yes. It is heavy cream and cheese, thickened with a little almond flour instead of a wheat flour roux.
How do I reheat it?
A film may form on top as it cools. That is not a problem: warm it gently over low heat and whisk until smooth again.
Can I substitute another cheese for Beecher’s Flagship?
You can. The recipe already uses sharp cheddar alongside the Flagship, so an all-cheddar version still works. You will lose some of the nutty depth that makes Flagship special.
Is this the Beecher’s grilled cheese recipe?
No. Beecher’s famous grilled cheese is a sandwich you can get at their Pike Place Market shop. This is our burger cheese sauce built on the same Flagship cheese, and it makes a killer dip for a grilled cheese, too.
Get the next recipe first.
New cooks, gear picks, and playlists in your inbox. No fluff, just fire.
One Comment