Tomahawk Ribeye w/ Compound Butter
The Tomahawk Steak is a winner for any party or special occasion and is sure to be the talk of the event. Just like its namesake, this steak looks aggressive, with a meaty flavor. Also referred to as a bone-in ribeye or cowboy steak, it’s flavorful and feeds a crowd from the cutting board well. We did a few for Father’s Day weekend alongside a NY Strip with friends served family style and the flavor was unreal.
So, check out our recipe for slow smoked on the Traeger, then reverse seared on our Weber gas grill, though you could modify easily to do on a Big Green Egg or gas grill with mesquite, pecan, and/or oak wood.
Sourcing a Tomahawk Ribeye
A tomahawk is a bone-in ribeye with the full rib bone left long and frenched, scraped clean of meat so it looks like a handle. A cowboy steak is the same cut with a shorter bone. Ask your butcher for a thick cut with good marbling through the eye and a fat cap on the spinalis, the rich outer ring that’s the best bite on the steak. Thick matters here: it gives you time to build smoke on the inside before the sear builds the crust on the outside.
Reverse Sear Temps: Smoke Low, Sear Hot
Reverse searing flips the usual order. The steak smokes at 225F first, so the whole cut comes up to temperature evenly instead of leaving a thick gray band under the crust. We pull at 119F in the thickest part of the eye, away from the bone, rest 10 minutes, then sear hard over 700F to build the crust. A leave-in probe thermometer with an alarm makes the pull easy to time.
For the sear we run GrillGrates on the Weber with only the burners under the steak lit. No gas grill? A ripping hot cast iron skillet or the bottom of a Big Green Egg with the lid open does the same job. The same method works on leaner roasts too; see our reverse seared eye of round.
| Doneness | Final internal temp after sear and rest |
|---|---|
| Rare | 120 to 125F |
| Medium rare | 130 to 135F |
| Medium | 140 to 145F |
The Compound Butter
Soften a stick of salted butter and mix in minced shallot and Italian parsley, roll it into a log in plastic wrap or parchment and freeze it while the steaks smoke. A cold disc on a hot, resting steak melts slowly and bastes the crust with butter, shallot and herbs right on the cutting board.
Ingredients
1-2 Tomahawk Steaks
Diamond Brand Kosher Salt
Fresh Cracked Black Pepper
Traeger Texas Beef Blend BBQ Pellets or pecan/mesquite/oak blend of your choice
Salt Lick Dry Rub
- For the Compound Butter
1 Stick Salted Butter
1 Tbsp Shallot
1 Tbsp Italian Parsley
Plastic wrap or Parchment paper
Directions
- Allow 1 stick butter to come to room temp.
- Rub steaks liberally with salt/pepper or Salt Lick Dry Rub. You can substitute your favorite rub. (Beer for scale)

- Set the Traeger to 225 degrees F and turn on Super Smoke if that’s an option on your grill.
- Rest the steaks at room temp for about an hour. With a boning knife you may want to clean up the rib and remove any excess fat.
- While the steaks rest, mix the ingredients for the Compound Butter. Form the mixture into a log on plastic wrap or parchment paper and put in the freezer.
- The steaks will “sweat”. Go ahead and pat them dry with a paper towel, pushing the rub into the meat.
- Place the steaks directly on the lower grate and let them smoke at 225F. This should take about 40-50 minutes depending on the size/thickness of the steak. I prefer to flip halfway through.

- Flip 20 minutes in and put a meat thermometer in the thickest part of the meat center that doesn’t touch bone and set the alarm for 119 degrees F. When it hits that target, pull the steaks and let them rest for 10 minutes.
- Get your “sear station” up to temp. In our case we use Grill Grates on a Weber that gets to over 700deg using two-zone cooking: only the burners over the steak are on. Alternatively you can foil the bones to keep them from charring.

- Let the steaks rest on a cutting board. Pull the compound butter from the freezer and slice into 1/4″ discs. Place one on each steak and watch it melt into the steak for about 10 minutes. Then slice across the grain and enjoy!

Slicing a Tomahawk Off the Bone
Once the butter has melted in, run a sharp knife along the bone to free the whole eye in one piece, then slice it across the grain and fan the slices back next to the bone for a family style platter. Save the bone for whoever called dibs. Round out the board with our Santa Maria tri-tip for a bigger crowd and a pan of smoked mac and cheese on the side.
Keep Going
- Smoked Prime Rib (Reverse Seared)
- Reverse Seared Eye of Round Roast
- How to Grill the Best Tri-Tip
- GrillGrates: Deceptively Simple, Amazing Results
- Chimichurri Stuffed Flank Steak
- Smoked Beecher’s Mac and Cheese
- Grilled Lamb Rib Cutlets
Get the next recipe first.
New cooks, gear picks, and playlists in your inbox. No fluff, just fire.