Slice of smoked prime rib on a Christmas plate with horseradish cream, jus, fondant potatoes and glazed carrots
| |

Smoked Prime Rib (Reverse Seared)

A smoked prime rib is the easiest showstopper you will ever put on a holiday table. Low smoke cooks it pink from edge to edge, and a few minutes over screaming hot heat at the end gives it the dark, peppery crust that makes people stop talking. We smoked a 5 lb boneless rib roast over charcoal, pulled it at 124°F, seared it hard, and carved it for Christmas dinner. Here is every temp and time from that cook. Don’t worry about equipment: pellet grill, offset, kamado or kettle, this works with them all.

Slice of smoked prime rib on a Christmas plate with horseradish cream, jus, fondant potatoes and glazed carrots

Why Smoke Prime Rib, Then Sear It

A hot oven cooks a roast from the outside in, so you get a thick gray band under the crust and a pink circle in the middle. Smoking low does the opposite. The whole roast comes up slowly and evenly, so by the time the center hits temp, the outer inch is barely behind it. That is the edge to edge pink you see in the photos.

The catch is that low heat never builds a crust. So we flip the usual order: smoke first, rest, then sear over open coals. This is the same reverse sear we use on our reverse seared eye of round roast, just with a much richer (and more expensive) cut.

Boneless or Bone-In Prime Rib

Both work. We cooked a boneless roast because it slices cleanly into even slabs and cooks a little faster, about 20 to 25 minutes per pound at 225°F. Bone-in takes closer to 30 minutes per pound and you carve the rack off before slicing. “Prime rib” is the name of the cut, the rib primal, not a promise of USDA Prime grade. A good Choice roast with plenty of marbling makes a great smoked prime rib. Budget about 3/4 lb per person boneless.

Tie, Oil and Season

Tie the roast with butcher twine every 1 1/2 inches. A boneless roast has nothing holding its shape, and the twine pulls it into one even log so the ends and the middle finish together. I give myself a B- on this tie but it worked.

Boneless prime rib roast tied with butcher twine on a wood cutting board before seasoning

Rub a thin coat of olive oil over every side as a binder, then coat it heavily with a simple mix of coarse kosher salt, coarse black pepper and dried garlic. That is the classic Texas style beef rub, and it is all beef this good needs. Do not be shy on the ends; that is where the crust lives and the first samples for the carving crowd come in.

Boneless prime rib roast coated in coarse salt, black pepper and dried garlic, ready for the smoker

Build the Jus Pan

Set the roast fat side up on a roasting rack over a pan with 2 cups of beef stock, half an onion, a few smashed garlic cloves and rosemary. Lay a couple of rosemary sprigs across the top of the roast too. Everything that drips off the beef lands in that stock and smokes along with it, and you strain it into jus at the end. Don’t be afraid to add more beef stock if it starts to go dry. Just don’t submerge the prime rib.

Seasoned prime rib on a roasting rack with rosemary, onion and garlic in the pan for jus

How to Smoke Prime Rib at 225°F

Any smoker or grill that holds a steady 225°F with indirect heat will do this: a pellet grill, an offset, a kamado with the plate setter in, or a kettle with the coals banked to one side. We cooked over a full load of lump charcoal with a heat deflector under the roast, plus two chunks of cherry and one of oak for smoke (on a pellet grill, cherry or a competition blend). Wait until the pit holds 225°F for 10 minutes before the roast goes on. On charcoal, choke the intake down early; a cooker that overshoots is slow to come back.

Prime rib roast in a roasting rack smoking over indirect heat on a charcoal grill

Where to Put the Probe

Go in from the side, level, at mid-height, so the tip sits in the center of the eye halfway down the roast’s length. The ends cook faster, and coming in from the side keeps the top clean for photos. Steer clear of the fat seam between the eye and the cap, or it will read high. We ran a FireBoard with an ambient probe clipped to the grate next to the roast, because that number, not the dome gauge, is the heat the meat actually sees.

FireBoard probe inserted into the side of a seasoned prime rib roast on a roasting rack

Smoked Prime Rib Temperature: When to Pull It

Our 5.22 lb roast went on just after 3 PM and read 124°F at 5:05 PM, a little under 2 hours. That lands right in the per pound window, even with the grate drifting up to about 258°F by the end. Go by the probe, never the clock. Pull the roast 5 to 10 degrees under your target; the rest and the sear carry it the rest of the way.

FireBoard thermometer reading 124°F internal on the smoked prime rib at the pull
  • Rare (125°F finished): pull at 115°F
  • Medium rare (130 to 135°F finished): pull at 118 to 124°F
  • Medium (140°F finished): pull at 128 to 130°F

Rest the roast while you build the sear fire, not after the sear. Twenty minutes tented loosely, with room for steam to escape, keeps it warm while the surface dries, and a dry surface takes a crust in 90 seconds instead of steaming.

Hawk’s Tip

How to Reverse Sear Prime Rib

Pull the roast and pan, tent the roast loosely with foil, and keep the jus pan warm. Now get your cooker as hot as it will go, 550°F or hotter at the grate. On charcoal or a kamado, pull the heat deflector, add fresh charcoal and open every vent. On a pellet grill, crank it to the top setting, or sear in a screaming hot cast iron skillet on the side burner or the stove.

Smoked prime rib with a mahogany bark in the roasting rack, just pulled before the reverse sear

Sear the roast directly over the fire (or in the skillet) for 60 to 90 seconds per side, rolling it a quarter turn at a time, then hold each end down for 30 seconds. Over live fire, expect flare ups from the fat cap; that is flavor, so let them lick it and keep it moving. Same move we use on a tomahawk ribeye, scaled up.

How to Carve and Serve Prime Rib

Rest the seared roast 10 minutes on a cutting board with a juice groove. Snip the twine, then carve across the grain into 3/4 inch slabs with a long slicing knife. One long stroke per slice keeps the crust on.

Strain the smoky jus from the pan into a small pot and taste it for salt. Stir together a quick horseradish cream: 1/2 cup sour cream, 2 tablespoons prepared horseradish, a squeeze of lemon and chopped chives. For our Christmas plate we served it with fondant potatoes and hot honey bourbon glazed carrots. Feeding a crowd? Our double smoked Christmas ham is the other half of the holiday table.

Smoked Prime Rib (Reverse Seared)

Recipe by The BBQ Hawks
0.0 from 0 votes

A boneless prime rib rubbed with coarse salt, pepper and garlic, smoked at 225°F over cherry and oak to 124°F, then reverse seared over high heat for a dark crust and edge to edge pink. Works on any smoker or grill.

Course: Main DishCuisine: BBQ, AmericanDifficulty: Medium
Servings

4

servings
Prep time

30

minutes
Cooking time

40

minutes

Ingredients

  • 5 to 6 lb boneless prime rib roast (rib roast), USDA Prime or Choice

  • 2 Tbsp olive oil

  • 3 Tbsp coarse kosher salt, 3 Tbsp coarse black pepper and 1 Tbsp granulated dried garlic, mixed

  • Butcher twine

  • 2 chunks cherry wood and 1 chunk oak (or cherry pellets)

  • Smoked Jus
  • 2 cups beef stock, plus more as needed

  • 1/2 yellow onion, cut in wedges

  • 4 garlic cloves, smashed

  • 3 sprigs fresh rosemary

  • Horseradish Cream
  • 1/2 cup sour cream

  • 2 Tbsp prepared horseradish

  • 1 tsp lemon juice

  • 1 Tbsp chopped chives

  • Pinch of kosher salt

Directions

  • Tie. Trim any loose fat and tie the roast with butcher twine every 1 1/2 inches so it cooks as one even log.
  • Season. Rub the roast all over with olive oil, then coat every side and both ends with the salt, pepper and garlic mix.
  • Build the jus pan. Pour the beef stock into a roasting pan, add the onion, garlic and 2 rosemary sprigs, and set a rack over it. Place the roast on the rack fat side up and lay the last rosemary sprig on top. Add more stock during the cook if the pan starts to go dry, but never submerge the roast.
  • Fire up. Set your smoker or grill for indirect heat at 225°F with the cherry and oak for smoke. On a charcoal grill, bank the coals to one side or use a heat deflector; on a kamado, use the plate setter. Hold 225°F for 10 minutes before the roast goes on.
  • Smoke. Insert a probe from the side into the center of the roast. Set the pan on the grate and smoke until the center reads 118 to 124°F for medium rare, about 20 to 25 minutes per pound (about 2 hours for a 5 lb roast).
  • Rest and build the sear. Pull the roast and pan and tent the roast loosely with foil for 20 to 30 minutes. Get the cooker as hot as it will go, 550°F or hotter: on charcoal or a kamado, remove the deflector, add fresh charcoal and open the vents; on a pellet grill, crank it to the top setting or heat a cast iron skillet until it smokes.
  • Sear. Sear the roast directly over the fire or in the skillet for 60 to 90 seconds per side, turning a quarter turn at a time, then sear each end for 30 seconds.
  • Make the sauces. Strain the pan juices into a small pot, taste for salt and keep hot. Stir the sour cream, horseradish, lemon juice, chives and salt together.
  • Carve. Rest the seared roast 10 minutes, cut the twine and slice across the grain into 3/4 inch slabs. Serve with the jus and horseradish cream.

Recipe Video

FAQ

Is prime rib actually Prime grade?

Not necessarily. Prime rib is the cut, a roast from the beef rib primal. The USDA grade is separate, and most prime rib sold is Choice. Prime grade has more marbling and costs more; a well-marbled Choice roast smokes beautifully.

How long does prime rib take to smoke at 225°F?

Plan on about 20 to 25 minutes per pound for boneless and about 30 minutes per pound for bone-in. Our 5.22 lb boneless roast took about 2 hours. Always cook to the probe, not the clock.

What temp do I pull prime rib for medium rare?

Pull at 118 to 124°F. The rest and the hot sear carry it to about 130 to 135°F, which is medium rare.

Do I need to rest prime rib after the sear?

Only briefly. It already rested before the sear, so 10 minutes on the board is enough to keep the juice in the meat when you slice.

Can I smoke prime rib on a pellet grill, kamado or kettle?

Yes. Any cooker that holds 225°F works. On a pellet grill, smoke at 225°F, then sear in a screaming hot cast iron pan or over a gas burner. On a Big Green Egg or other kamado, smoke with the plate setter in, then pull it and open the vents for the sear. On a kettle, bank the coals to one side for the smoke, then sear directly over a fresh chimney of hot coals.

Keep Going

One Comment

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.